<B/>

Don't demand Global Solutions when Local ones suffice

Started Last edited

This is a concept I see used way less often than it should be used, in my opinion:

How global or local a solution for a problem is.

What does that mean?

If you want to cross a river, swimming across it is a local solution. Building a bridge for others to use is a global solution.

If you’re cold, putting on one more sweater is a local solution. Turning up your heating is a global solution.

If you want to listen to music, putting in earphones is a local solution. Turning up the music on your phone is a global solution.

If you’re ill, putting on a mask (or staying in your room) is a local solution, asking the choir to do their rehearsal outside is a (more) global solution.

Locality and Globality lie on a spectrum.

If you’re cold, it might be that actually just your feet are cold, so one ordering of solutions from local to global would be Putting on Socks < Putting on a sweater < Heating up the room < Heating up the home < Heating up the whole planet.

Solutions are local and global in how much they affect their environment.

I think that in general, local solutions are wildly preferable to global ones. That affecting others less rather than more, if you have the option, is a good idea seems pretty obvious to me—but we wouldn’t be here if it were absolutely clear for everyone.

And here’s why:

§1

Often, people have conflicting needs. You trying to solve a problem of yours with a global solution will add a new problem onto the stack of problems that all of the other people around you that have a conflicting need with you already have.11 A principle that comes close, but isn’t sharp enough for my taste is Considerateness

§2

Which in and of itself is annoying, but often easy to handle.22 In many places on earth, we do it multiple times a day even just for temperature There are however some global solutions that are hard to reverse locally by yourself. The clearest example I know here is air CO2.

It’s very easy to bring it down “globally” by opening the window. But it’s very hard to work against a group of people who don’t want to do that, and refuse to open the windows. (You can literally only bring an oxygen bottle with you, and breathe in and out with a mask.)

So it’s easy to reverse the global solution (air a room, and with that make it cooler)—but it’s (sometimes) hard to impossible to reverse the effects of a global solution with a local one (carrying your own oxygen supply around with you).

Let’s call that easy and hard local reversibility.

Temperature is something where there’s an area where there is easy reversibility for the most time, and then reversibility suddenly gets hard.

  • It’s bad to feel cold and it’s pretty annoying33 but imho a bit less bad to feel too warm and sweat.
  • Just feeling too warm without sweating seems slightly annoying to me.
  • It’s easy to shed a layer if you’ve got more than one on and feel too warm.
  • It’s easy to add a layer when you feel too cold.
  • There’s different comfort temperatures for different people.
  • But at some point when the temperature gets too hot (for some people), the local solutions start to get more annoying: You then place your feet in cold water, regularly sprinkle water over you to benefit from evaporative cooling, and such.

(and hint, hint, those are always the ones that go against the baseline of the environment we’ve evolved in. We’ve evolved being outside, so that’s what we’re naturally good at. We’re good at getting warm (movement), and good at not getting too hot (sweating), provided we have enough water. We’re not good at being in stuffy places for long periods of time, because they don’t exist in the savannah.)

§3

And obviously the global solutions also have side effects44 so effects that happen as a byproduct of the effects you want to achieve most of the time. The easy example here is, again, keeping a room warm by heating up the air and not opening the windows, which will affect air CO2 and ease of infection together with the intended effect of keeping the room warm.

Other examples of this would be daylight saving time (which has lots of side effects on humans in the weeks of the change).

§4

So, are global solutions always bad? No, there’s obviously reasons that global solutions are pretty great, too. Even though they are interacting with your other needs way more, they are often simpler for the people using them. E.g. owning a car (+ streets) is a more local solution to the problem of “getting somewhere” than using public transport. But at the same time, you need to recharge or get gas for it regularly, you need to clean it, bring it to the mechanic from time to time, you need to park it everywhere you go, and so on. That’s not to say that a car can’t make your life easier compared to public transport, but it probably won’t make it simpler most of the time.

And I think that this property of (some) global solutions (that they actually make life simpler for most of the people, most of the time) might be the point of calling something “infrastructure”?

§5

I think that infrastructure is a particularly interesting case. This definitely is a global solution, but it seems like a ‘good’ global solution? Do we actually feel something belongs into the class of ‘Infrastructure’ only when this requirement (that it’s a worth it and ‘good’ global solution) is satisfied?

Because we could all happily produce our own electricity, not have any roads or bridges or railways (and walk or bike or drive or helicopter everywhere just through fields and woods).55 In that sense even having property is a very global solution to a problem? But that’s for another time.

The difference with all of these things in the infrastructure category, I think, is that all of these provide extreme positive externalities and freedom (or they make bad externalities not happening cheap), and there is not really a good, similarly expensive local solution to them.

Like maaybe we could do without trains and roads in our helicopters and monster trucks, but that sounds like a bunch of very expensive local solutions.

But enough of that sidequest (for now, to be continued).


So, to sum up:

There’s a spectrum from local to global in the solutions that exist for problems. And to not potentially make the world worse for all of the people around you, please start tackling the problem with local solutions, first.

§FAQ

§But isn’t “using local solutions” just being considerate/respectful/thoughtful?

No.

At least not exactly:

The problem here is that using these words gives us a more coarse resolution of reality, and we can do better than them. Because people don’t only use them when they are annoyed about you using a more global solution when a more local one would’ve been sufficient, but as a general way to make you be quiet when they don’t like you.

(Like: You dressing weird is a very local thing to do, and shouldn’t, in general, bother anyone, but is definitely something you’d get “Hey, that’s not respectful”s for)

§Footnotes

  1. A principle that comes close, but isn’t sharp enough for my taste is Considerateness ↩

  2. In many places on earth, we do it multiple times a day even just for temperature ↩

  3. but imho a bit less bad ↩

  4. so effects that happen as a byproduct of the effects you want to achieve ↩

  5. In that sense even having property is a very global solution to a problem? But that’s for another time. ↩